Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Stereo Recording Exercise (from 9/11/14)

For this project my group mates (Dana and Taka) and I experimented with different microphone set ups in two different spaces.  Due to time restraints a third and recording mistakes there was not enough class time to complete an exercise for a "small reverberant space."  After listening, taking notes, and comparing, here are my personal findings.

Location A: Large Reverberant Space: (specifically The KSA parking Garage)

     The best mic set up bar none was the near coincident set up with the NT3s.  Being that in order to capture the expansive, echoey nature of the space, the wider coverage afforded by the "near-coincident" technique captured the truth of the space.  Also to see how each set up captured the verisimilitude of different kinds of sounds in the space, we had Taka walk past the mics in a linear motion while jingling his keys.  In the "Near-Coincident" recording, the jingling of the keys is preserved along with the ambient hums and bangs of the machinery in the garage, and not muddled.  In other words, the different characters of the depth and character of different sounds in the space were preserved.  On the flip side, the worst recording of the space was captured by the "A-B" technique.  Because Taka walked on the left of the mic set up, all of the sound produced by the keys when he passed the mics was absorbed by the left mic.  The result was a period of muted and distorted audio that masked the other sounds of the space.

Location C:  Outdoors, Open Space (specifically, Oak Leaf Trail Bike path stretch next to Kenilworth)

     I though the best mic set up for the space we visited was the "X-Y" technique.  Being that this was a natural environment, there was a lot of wind, and with the wind the noise of moving grass and leaves.  Under other microphone setups, the overwhelming dominance of these sounds washed out the recording, specifically the "Near-Coincident" which gave too much of a range for wind to enter into the mics and blur out the sounds.  But in the "X-Y" set up, the tightness of the stacked mics range allowed for greater distinction.  I still think wind was an issue, but in this recording, I could distinguish the rustling of grass and leaves.  Since we used the sound of the grass as our marker, this was a good thing.  Other mic setups of note that failed was using the "A-B" variation set up in bi-directional.  This was mainly because in our set up, one of the mics was pointed towards the grass we were trying to listen to and the other away towards the street.  This caused a completely uneven mix of the grass being overpowered by wind and traffic.  While the choice to perform the setup in this way could be contributed to human error, changing positioning would still have resulted in an uneven recording, since wind was only flowing in one direction at the time and would've been absorbed by one mic.

OF NOTE:
While we were unable to perform test recordings in a small reverberant space, I've recorded this type of space on my Scavenger hunt assignment and thought I'd share my opinions.  I recorded sound in the bathroom at my work, while it was empty of course, because it has this strange dripping sound, and I used that as a guide for the mics.  While I didn't end up using the space for the assignment, because of sound drifting in from the hall, I found the best recording technique was again near coincident.  I think because the natural acoustics of the room allowed the dripping to reverberate evenly, the range provided by the set up gave an accurate presentation.  I didn't perform an "A-B" variation, but going off experience and assumption I think I would've picked up uneven sounds from the toilets in the room as they got absorbed by separate mics.

No comments:

Post a Comment